top of page


Amy made me the most incredible Twilight cookies for my Twilight themed birthday party! Stunning, delicious, show stopping, I can't recommend them enough!

Shelby T. 3/9/23

Found Coveted cookies online. Easy ordering. Amy was very nice and made cookies for my daughters bridal shower. She was able to replicate a picture of what I wanted she even worked with me when I changed my mind on the coloring. Cookies turned out amazing and are very delicious cookies. I would definitely recommend using Coveted Cookies. I will use her again. 5 Stars. Thank you

Kimberly C. 2/5/23

I will definitely be using this business again! I gave her a very basic idea of what I wanted and she made them better than I could have pictured and exactly what I was wanting! They were gorgeous, tasted as good or, if possible, better than they looked, and the communication and customer service was outstanding!! This was the first time I have ever ordered these type of cookies and I looked into and compared many places. Her prices were fair and reasonable and worth every penny and then some!! Highly recommend!

Brooke J.  3/20/21

Top notch service from start to finish. I couldn't say enough great things about The Coveted Cookie. If you've made it far enough to read this review book your cookies now you won't be disappointed.

Courtney L.

Delicious and beautiful cookies! Great communication from owner/baker during order and pickup.

Marissa S.

A wiz with detailed cookies! The Coveted Cookie is super communicative during the entire process. The cookies were beautiful and delicious!

Chris F.

the cookies for my son's first birthday were absolutely amazing! not just the time and art work to make them look good, but they tasted amazing as well! thank you so much!

Tiffany P.

Such a beautiful set of cookies made for my daughters first birthday! Great attention to detail and they were delicious!! Highly recommend!

Jennifer S.

She made beautiful cookies for my husbands birthday and they were delicious!

Molly S.

Easy to work with! Sent some inspiration pictures and she delivered! Cookies were delicious and definitely a hit at our Safari themed first birthday!

Ryann W.

Cookies were super creative and tasted amazing!!

Brittney O.

I got my cookie order from Amy Scott - The Coveted Cookie today! They are fabulous, and really have a lot of great detail.

Doris M.

She made my request come to life and they were so much fun! Not to mention delicious.

Cassidy C.

Purchased a DIY Valentine’s Day cookie set. Great tasting and very nicely put together. Great communication as well. Will definitely be ordering in the future.

Summer N.

I purchased 14 valentine cookies for my coworkers!! And they exceeded my expectations wonderfully. Not Only were they eye pleasing but soft and super flavorful!!

Marlena K.

Loved the mini cookies for Valentine’s Day! I really appreciated that the owner made a smaller box for me and my daughter so we didn’t have to get 12 cookies! They were realllllly tasty and the set up was perfect. All we had to do was cut the tip of the icing bag and decorate. Will definitely order again for future kits!

Brandee A.

Absolutely love my Coveted Cookies! My husband surprised me with a dozen roses. They are so beautiful and so delicious! Thank you!

Kimberly W.

Thanks for the early Valentine’s Day gift, Dad! These are so delicious and look beautiful! The packaging was sturdy and every cookie looked perfect! Definitely will be ordering some more as a gift, or for myself, soon!

Stephanie W.

We needed dairy free treats for my sons first birthday, not only did Amy amaze us with her cookies but they were also vegan! Our guests gave so many compliments on the Mickey Mouse cookies and the kids all devoured them! I love supporting fellow military spouses and Amy is very talented!

KaSara J.

I ordered cookies for daughters tea party birthday party. Not only did Amy match the cups perfectly to the cups we were using for the party but they were also delicious! Not too sweet, just right All of the girls and mommas loved them. I will definitely use The Coveted Cookie again!

Courtney F.

The cookies were so well decorated, very detailed and personalized. Not to mention, DELICIOUS! Perfectly baked. Will definitely order from here again for the next special event!

Rachel K.

The cookies were so well decorated, very detailed and personalized. Not to mention, DELICIOUS! Perfectly baked. Will definitely order from here again for the next special event!

Sierra O.

Amy made custom cookies for my husbands Chief pinning ceremony. They were identical to what I was looking for, and they were all eaten in a matter of minutes! I would recommend her a million times over. Thank you!

Desiree H.

Her cookies were not only beautiful but they were so delicious! Our family was so impressed. We will definitely be ordering again!

Lauren H.

Delicious cookies that look great. Huge hit with the family.

Kayla G.

Add a Testimonial

As a brand new business that began in January 2021, your input about your experience is invaluable to me. If there was anything you particularly were pleased with or think I could improve on, I'd love to hear about it. Please rate and add a testimonial about you experience.

Would you recommend us to your friends?

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page